首页Home/评审规则Judging rules

好设计,有清晰的判断依据。A clear framework for good design.

西安首站机器人概念设计征集。以设计概念为主要评审对象,不要求已量产或具备完整工程样机。The Xi’an robot concept design call reviews design concepts. A production-ready product or complete engineering prototype is not required.

评分维度 · 总分100分Assessment · 100 points

维度Criterion分值Points评审关注Review focus
理念与任务Idea & purpose20目标人群、需求、场景是否清晰,方案是否与任务相称。Clarity of audience, need and context; fitness of the idea for its purpose.
形态与表达Form & expression20外观、比例、结构和运动姿态是否相互支持。How form, proportions, structure and intended motion work together.
功能与互动Function & interaction20操作、反馈、玩法、能力边界与实现路径是否可信。Use, feedback, rules, limits and a plausible realization path.
独特性Differentiation20与已有方案的实质差异,超越视觉包装的贡献。A meaningful difference from comparable work beyond appearance.
责任与可持续性Responsibility & sustainability20安全、包容、维修、材料寿命,以及相关隐私和社会影响。Safety, inclusion, repair, life cycle, and relevant privacy and social effects.

评分锚点与证据阶段Scoring anchors and evidence stage

每项为0–20的整数。0–4:关键问题未回答;5–9:方向可辨、证据不足;10–14:方案完整;15–17:完成度高且证据可信;18–20:该维度格外出色。评委分别记录概念、仿真、原型或实际测试阶段;无需实体原型也可取得高分,但不得将渲染或仿真写成实际测试。Integer scores per criterion: 0–4 unanswered, 5–9 weakly supported, 10–14 coherent, 15–17 strong with credible evidence, 18–20 exceptional. Jurors record whether a project is a concept, simulation, prototype or tested work. A physical prototype is not required for a high score, but renderings and simulations must not be presented as real tests.

01 · 资格与材料核验01 · Eligibility & material checks

确认作品完整性、原创声明、AI 使用披露及作者授权。个人或团队均可投稿;未成年参赛者须取得监护人同意。Check completeness, originality declarations, AI disclosures, and creator permissions. Individuals and teams may enter. Minors require guardian consent.

02 · 独立评分与回避02 · Independent review & recusal

进入评审的作品由无利益冲突的评审员独立评分。系统持续显示实际评审进度;三份评分不再是管理员确认和公示结果的硬性门槛,管理员可根据现有评分及评议记录人工确认结果并记录理由。评审员须申报与作者的合作、指导、雇佣或其他可能影响公正的关系并回避。Reviewers without conflicts independently assess eligible entries. Actual review progress remains visible. Three scorecards are not a prerequisite for an administrator to confirm or publish a result; the organizer may decide using available scores and deliberation, with a recorded rationale. Reviewers must disclose and recuse themselves from collaboration, teaching, employment, or other relationships that may compromise impartiality.

03 · 评议与结果确认03 · Deliberation & decisions

每位评委在五个维度分别填0–20分。每项取有效评分平均数,五项相加得到总分(显示一位小数)。总分最高与最低相差超过20分,或任一维度相差超过10分时,评审团讨论并记录理由。分数为评议依据;同分及最终决定由评审团讨论并记录理由。入围及奖项分别确认;具体奖项设置另行公布。Each juror scores five criteria from 0 to 20. The average for each criterion is added to a total displayed to one decimal place. A total spread above 20, or any criterion spread above 10, triggers a documented panel discussion. Scores inform deliberation; ties and final decisions are resolved with recorded reasons. Shortlists and awards are confirmed separately; categories will be announced.

04 · 线下展示遴选04 · Exhibition selection

根据作品质量、主题、展示可行性、场地条件及作者授权确认展出。入围不自动等于获奖;支付展出服务费不购买奖项,不改变已完成的评选结果。Exhibition selection considers quality, theme, display feasibility, venue conditions, and creator permission. Shortlisting is not an award. Exhibition fees do not purchase awards or alter completed judging decisions.

异议与更正Objections & corrections

结果发布后7个自然日内,可邮件提出程序、利益冲突、侵权或事实错误异议,并附作品编号及依据。组织方应记录、核查并答复;对专业判断的不同意见不自动触发重评。法定救济权利不受影响。Within seven calendar days of publication, email concerns about procedure, conflicts, rights, or factual errors with your entry ID and evidence. Organizers will record, investigate, and respond. Disagreement with professional judgment does not automatically require a re-score. Lawful remedies remain available.

准备并提交作品Prepare and submit

结果确认与统一公示Decision and scheduled publication

管理员确认结果后,按设定的北京时间统一公示。系统在到时后分批向通知范围内的报名参赛者发送获奖或参展信息及最终评分PDF;内部上传作品不自动向作者发送邮件。未完成结果确认的投稿不会自动被判为未入围。最终评分只统计公示时有效正式评分的平均值,草稿和回避评分不计入;无评分时注明暂无有效评分。公示和获奖结果与缴费独立。Confirmed results are released at the scheduled Beijing time. The system then sends result information and final score PDFs in batches to registered entrants in the selected recipient scope. Internal uploads do not trigger creator emails. Undecided entries are not automatically rejected. Final averages use valid submitted scorecards at publication, excluding drafts and recusals; missing scores are marked unavailable. Publication and awards are independent of payment.